The long legal battle between Ripple Labs and the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) recently took an interesting turn. A win Ripple?
On the 28th of Wednesday, Judge Analisa Torres delivered the verdict, which sparked ripples in the Crypto industry as she fined Ripple $125 million subsequently declining the SEC’s request for $2 billion (€1.6bn) in damages.
The Verdict and its Direct Impact
The court ruling led to % spike in Ripple’s token, XRP, by over 20%. Such dramatic market movements highlights the importance of the case which has been under the radar of most if not all Crypto enthusiasts and investors since 2020.
Despite that, Judge Torres’s decision of penalising Ripple failed to meet SEC demands. The SEC found the $125 million (€113mn) penalty too low, having sought $1 billion (€910mn) and a future ban.
A Nuanced Victory
As Ripple executives celebrate this court ruling, scholars are more cautious about it. Joe Castelluccio, a partner at Mayer Brown and co-leader of the firm’s fintech and Blockchain practice groups, said he thought the decision was “very positive for Ripple.” Still, this indication of scepticism is warranted since it should “give the industry and the market a bit of pause.”
The differences are not entirely trivial as they explain why the ruling is subtler than it may initially appear. Thus, Judge Torres concluded that Ripple’s sales of XRP to institutional customers was unlawful. At the same time, they were legal in the secondary market and exchanges, making it a Crypto regulations topic.
Appeals and Uncertainty
However, this may be where the rug is pulled under Ripple, even though it seems the company has triumphed. The SEC will likely appeal the ruling, particularly on issues related to secondary sales and the stipulated fine amount. This is a clear reminder of the yet not so clear Crypto industry regulations the market has been waiting for.
Ostensibly, other federal judges have made divergent opinions in similar cases. This leaves a tangled web of legal decisions requiring clarification at the appellate or Supreme Court level.
The Ripple case has become one of the defining moments for the Cryptocurrency industry, resulting in justifiable fights against regulatory agencies. However, given that the appeal process takes much longer than the trial, final appellate decisions may be made as late as 2025, while any Supreme Court determination may not be made until 2026 or beyond.
Also, there is a need for the political class to react to such issues, implying that there is a high likelihood that Congress shall formulate new rules to address some of the legal challenges in the courts.
Conclusion
As Ripple and its backers are over the roof with this latest court ruling, it is unclear what the future holds for the Cryptocurrency industry. Uncertainty remains on legal precedents, current court decisions, and the probability of new laws that will directly affect the regulation of digital assets.
Still, the Crypto space awaits further developments. Thus, one thing is clear: The Ripple case remains one of the most defining events in the present-day debate amongst innovators, investors and regulators.
Image Source: Adobe Stock
Disclaimer: This article is provided for informational purposes only. It is not offered or intended to be used for legal, tax, investment or financial advice.
